Showing posts with label Finance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Finance. Show all posts

Thursday, March 12, 2009

Cook the book ?

Accountancy is not only science but a very sophisticated art as well , Purpose of this article is just to look at different methods which companies use from time to time to present a different picture of thier books , none of these methods can provide any long term benefit , all they can assure is trouble. Real profit is some thing which is earned by a direct increase of top and bottom line and not just be shifting numbers here and there.

depreciation : Depreciation is an highly effective tool of cooking books , specially for manufacturing and logistics companies which have huge capital investments in machineries and vehicles. Suppose the average industry practice is to depreciate a lath machine for 10 years but some smart company thinks it can depreciate similar machine for 15 years , this kind of tweaking will be effective enough to bring the books from red zone to green as the
earning will be increased because lesser depreciation is being subtracted .

COGS : If Cost of goods sold is subtracted from the revenue that gives gross profit , Further subtractions of operational expenses, interests payments and taxes will take us to the net profit. If one wants to increase gross profit artificially the easy way is to move the cost of goods sold towards operational expense. There will be some smart accountants who found arguments for the same.

Showing earnings in advance : In service industry there are contracts which can be as long as 5 to 7 years , if 40% of the money comes from software development than 60% is from maintainace and support. If an organization is getting into a contract with its client which is about delivering a software as well as supporting it for next 5 years , then it can show any fraction ( as liked by its accountants) of this revenue at any time in the books
and guess what its perfectly legal.

Goodwill : one of the best ways to create an impressive asset base is to increase the goodwill, whenever an organization aquires another there is lot more than just physical property. Mainly a huge client list , good work force , a well established brand etc. all can be put under goodwill. In addition to this if some of the value from plant , property can also be shifted to goodwill , that will mean no depreciation charging for such assets in turn direct impact on the bottom line.

Bill and hold : This has been a very popular accounting technique in many of the organizations which asked their corporate customers to purchase much earlier then the business cycle and pay only after sale has taken place. The purchase made was billed and showed as a revenue in current cycle, very clearly this can work only one odd time.

Saturday, June 21, 2008

ABC of Creative Costing

In traditional costing system it was a simple method because it was made for a simple era , imagine why would Mr Ford need to worry anything in traditional costing after all , he had to produce only one thing and that was black cars . Ford wasn't changing any model in earlier days , forget about model he wasn't even changing colors of the cars and in such a case traditional costing made perfect sense where all the overhead and other costs were proportioned equally to the number of units produced . there was hardly any confusion or apprehension about costing .

No one would have imagined in those days that a process as simple as finding out cost of labor , material , sales and administration and allocating it to number of units will become so creative in coming days. Very soon days of monopoly and cost plus were on their out from industry , it was time to produce more and with various varieties . ( just after one decade GM would have near 8000 model of cars in its portfolio). Then started the problem , not all the product needed same kind of materials neither were they produced by similar processes . Some of them were simple and needed easily available materials but some were specific which needed expensive material and special treatments. In fact Cost differentiation started much before manufacturing , In case of motherboard , chips or other research extensive electronics product research and design also contributed to the cost and determined the way these products need to be produced during manufacturing.

These complexities gave birth to a new comprehensive and creative way of costing , Activity based costing where no longer the cost was a simple function of direct labour , direct material with equal distribution of overhead to all the products . In ABC each phase of product lifecycle was divided into various activities and cost incurred in each activities was calculated , this obviously gave a clearer picture rather then a generic overview.

What were some of the basic points to consider while deciding between ABC and traditional cost.

Disillusionment :
At times traditional cost created illusions , lets take a very bookish example which is there in almost all costing books . If a car manufacturer is manufacturing cars of two types one is standard cars which are made in assembly line and completely automated whereas another types of cars are competing head on with Maybach ( Remember these high end cars in which entire interiors is done by hands) and after making these two kind of cars he is simply dividing the total cost incurred in making them by number of units produced , obviously he would now find that the margin for his standard cars have decreased .....
traditional costing created this kind of false illusions for management which may lead to disastrous decisions like closing down production of standard cars or increasing the price of these cars . ABC helped management in such situations by providing them precise information

Hitting right on the correct problem : In earlier days when major portion of motherboard fabrication was done by hands in HP , they found that over all cost for motherboards was high and the obvious blame was on manufacturing . What they missed is two things
1) How will the device be manufactured is decided much earlier in design phase
2) Manual fabrication is much costlier then automated manufacturing.
These are typical example where either a product need some special treatment or one of the process in product development is eating larger chunk f resources then other processes . In such case we need to concentrate only on those pain areas.

Traditional costing could have never detected these issues , it was again ABC which came to the rescue .

Importance for service industry : Traditional costing could have never done justice to service industry . In service industry there is no tangible product to be delivered , every service is simply combination of activities . To find out which activity is costliest you need to apply ABC and once you have done so , you can decide on next strategic move , whether you should keep such activity with you or outsource it to some third party vendors.


Similarly there is one very crucial question which traditional costing will never be able to answer and that is which customer is causing more cost or which is the most profitable customer.
In short here ABC can help you providing right set of services to right set of customers

Sunday, April 27, 2008

Billions of enterprises to enterprises of billions

Time of small has come , last year apple released its ipod nano which was smallest and sleekest in the family and after that there was much hyped dream of Mr Tata , Tata Nano which shown to the world that small is really disruptive it can bring a paradigm change in the industries and prove that impossible is nothing . There was a time when people used to long for big , today the liking has changed ( If we keep some exceptions like real estate out) and it has been rapidly caught up by Industry biggies , at one side Fijitsu and Apple have come up with the smallest laptop this year on the other side from mobile to hard disk everything is shrinking into a pocket size portable device.Now the question is does small mean that it has some tradeoffs , is it compromising something ? Today in most of the cases answer is no. Small is as powerful as its larger counterpart and whenever small comes into market, it instantly becomes favourite of masses. A very comparable trend has been seen from last couple of years in industry, there is a huge surge in number of small and medium size industries worldwide. These SMEs are emerging as the growth engine of the world economy . In the EU, SMEs comprise approximately 99% of all firms and employ between them about 65 million people. In China there are close to 8 million SMEs and in India the number is 4.5 million.SMEs are also responsible for driving innovation and competition. These are the businesses which later on become some of the largest empires in the world, recall the days when Infosys started with 5 man and a two BHK apartment in Pune and went on to become the second largest software services provider in Asia . At one side where big stalwarts of India Inc are making news worldwide, back home the efforts of the small and medium enterprises are also gaining appreciation and support from all the dimensions.





Great Governance :

Indian government has been closely monitoring the development in SME sector and formulating many supportive policies to boost it further and it has to definitely do this for a sector which employs more then 178 lakh people. For funding SMES financial institutions like Small Industries Development Bank of India (SIDBI) , National Small Industries Corporation have been instituted . the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has already issued guidelines to the public sector banks to ensure 20 per cent year-on-year growth in credit to the SME , other banks are also encouraged to provide loans to SMEs .


Advocacy by Non profit associations:

Most of the Industry associations like CII , FICCI , NASSCOM which represent all sections of industry have not only setup a separate wing catering to the SMBs but also started encouraging SMEs by giving away various awards in almost all of the verticals where SMEs are functional. One of the most talked about awards is "Emerging India Award" which is instituted by ICICI in collaboration with CRISIL. Corporation bank has also initiated an ward called National award for mSME which will be focussing on sector wise contribution of mSMEs. As per my understanding the most critical role played by these authorities is by doing advocacy for SMEs with government as well as private organizations specially banks , this helps in bringing attention to the areas of improvement and creating better opportunities for SMEs. It is because of these effortsmany organizations are joining hands with regulatory bodies and trying to come up with solution and funding products for SMEs. Media is also fully supportive of these efforts.


Now IT is easy :

There was a time when arrogance of IT companies was at peek , it was impossible for anyone to realise that any small business can leverage on power of the mighty mainframe or for that matter any state of art computing facility like data centres and storage solutions but today rules of the game have changed . IT companies have suddenly started targeting and building solutions for SMEs not only because they want to help SMEs grow larger but They have also realised this is where their future top and bottom line is. As per the latest Microsoft-AMI Partners report, "the India SMEs are on a firm growth trajectory, with 60 per cent of PC-using businesses expecting 20 per cent growth and 16 per cent planning to add branch offices to expand operations". Some of the classic example of these focussed solutions are storage product by Sun , HP , Toshiba , Network solutions by Cisco , nortel . Another breakthrough in this space is emergence of software as service have given value for the cost put in by SMEs as they only pay for what they use and hence they are not bound to purchase complete packages to use just a small part of it. Now setting up IT infrastructure is possible in very affordable prices for SMEs thanks to the concepts of platform as service and On-Demand delivery model enabling firms to move their entire IT infrastructure management to the ‘multi-tenant system’ shared resources where complete infrastructure can be leased or rented .


Environment :

Whenever entrepreneurial ventures are discussed , we always discuss successes and not failures whereas more then 80% of start-ups never complete their one year of existence . I see this a good sign for other entrepreneurs because they always have fascinating success stories like virgin , FedX , Infoys , Microsoft , Dominos , Air Deccan to follow and no failures which can cause any hesitation in their minds. Visionaries like Dhiru bhai Ambani gave a life to this word "Entrepreneur". Entrepreneurship today is the most respected occupation !


This is the time when SMEs have a perfect balance of opportunities and sources to leverage on those opportunities , at one side globalization is continuously opening new opportunities for industry and on the other technology enablement like ecommerce.


There is no dearth of talent specially when they are sitting in the hub of worlds coast arbitrage centre.It is worth appreciating that everyone is realising that one size does not fit all and hence special nurturing is needed in case of these small but powerful giants. The quest for searching new growth avenues never stops , up to now we are master in putting lower categories up in value chain and so will be done here as well , the concept of micro small and medium enterprises has already caught up the momentum and given various supporting factor there is every possibility for each of these billions of enterprises to become enterprises of billions.

Wednesday, April 16, 2008

Kautilya's 7 pillars of organzation .

The ancient wisdom which Chankaya had passed to us is amazing , It penetrates two main areas of any orgaization 1) Finance ( Arthshashtra) and 2) Organizational structure and Roles and Responsibilities.
Here is an example of what chanakya's opinion was about organizational structure. In one of the verses of Arthshastra he quotes
Swami , Amatya , Janapada , Durg , Kosha , Danda , Mitra , Iti Prakariyet.
These are the seven main componenets of any organizations
AS par kautilaya shastra it is very important for any kingdom to keep all of these 7 factors intact for smooth functioning of the nation . Following are the 7 pillars mentioned by Chankaya.
Internal constituents :
following 5 internal constituents are important for an organization
(a) Swami: The master or king of the nation who rules the nation and has complete control , he is not involved in day to day activities of the nation . Swami is responsible for building long term strategic plans for growth of the nation
(b) amatya : bureaucracy, often loosely described as ministry, They work directly under Swami and control all functioning on his behalf .
(c) durga: fort, often identified as city (pura),
(d) artha or Kosha : treasury or finance of the nation . Kosha is accumulated earning from the janapada which is used for several purposes.
(e) danda : army of the nation. Danda is the workforce of the kingdom which is instrumental in any key implementation and execution of the task

External constituents :
As per chanakya there are two external constituents which affect any organization
(a) Janpada : Rrural hinterland, Can be translated as the end users or stakeholders who are directly affected by what is done by Kingdom.
(b) Mitra : friends of the nation who can help them in the crisis situation .

In todays organizations , these can be compared as given below
1) Swami is represented by the CEO of the organization
2) Amatyas are represented by different managers of the oranization
3) Durg is the headquarter of organization
4) Kosha is the reserves with organization
5) Danda is the workforce of the organization
6) Janapada is the market which organization serves
7) Mitra are partners and other allies of organization

Any activiy or problem of organization can surely be fit into one of these seven pillars and then can be solved accordingly !!

Based on a discussion with Mr Radhakrishnan Pillai , Management evangelist and strategic consultant